Use this rubric to evaluate your peer's argumentative paragraph. Be honest and constructive in your feedback.
| Element | Excellent (3) | Good (2) | Needs Improvement (1) | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Main Idea (Claim) | Clear and strong claim | Claim present but could be stronger | Claim is unclear or missing | |
| Evidence | Strong evidence from the text | Some evidence, but could be stronger | Little or no evidence | |
| Explanation | Clear explanation of how evidence supports claim | Some explanation, but could be clearer | Little or no explanation | |
| Writing Quality | Well-written, clear, and organized | Mostly clear, some organization issues | Unclear or disorganized |
Provide specific feedback for your peer's paragraph. What did they do well? What could they improve?
Use this checklist as you revise your paragraph based on peer feedback.