Persuasive Paragraph Worksheet: The Gift of the Magi

Directions:

Write a persuasive paragraph in which you argue the following: "Was the sacrifice Della made for Jim truly an act of love or foolishness?" Use evidence from the story to support your claim. Be sure to explain your reasoning clearly and refer to specific parts of the story using the sentence starters below.

1. Topic Sentence

Begin your paragraph with a clear topic sentence that states your opinion on whether Della’s sacrifice was an act of love or foolishness.

2. Reasons and Evidence

Provide at least two reasons for your opinion. Use the sentence starters below to help you reference specific details from the story. Be sure to include textual evidence (quotes or paraphrases) to support your reasons.

Sentence Starters:

  • "In the story, Della shows her love for Jim by ____."
  • "This is evident when the author writes, '____,' which shows ____."
  • "Della's actions suggest that she believed ____ because ____."
  • "For example, when Della says, '____,' it highlights ____."
  • "While some may see Della's sacrifice as foolish, I believe it demonstrates ____ because ____."

Reason 1: Write your first reason and include textual evidence from the story.

Reason 2: Write your second reason and include textual evidence from the story.

3. Conclusion

End your paragraph with a strong conclusion that restates your opinion and sums up your argument.